Journal Archives

Welcome to Andrew's e-journal!


This is the website of Andrew David Field, long-term Shanghai resident, historian, teacher, and scholar of Chinese studies, author of Shanghai's Dancing World:  Cabaret Culture and Urban Politics, 1919-1954 (Chinese University Press, 2010)

and co-author of Shanghai Nightscapes:  The Making of a Nighttime Metropolis, 1910-2010 (forthcoming from University of Chicago Press).  I try to keep up regular journal entries on my tours, experiences, ideas, and insights into urban culture and society in China's great metropolis.  Please enjoy this website and feel free to provide your own comments.

798 Arts District Academia alumni Amy Chua apocatropolis Art Art Deco Astronomy Australia Ba Jin Bad Girl Fiction Beijing Beijing Olympics blues Blues and Jazz Bob Dylan Book Review Book Reviews Buddhism bund Cchinese culture CChinese Indie Rock Chairman Mao Changsha Chen Liangyu China China Bounder China Journalism Chinese Cinema chinese culture Chinese Folk Music chinese history Chinese Indie Rock Chinese Intellectuals Chinese Literature Chinese Minorities Chinese Mothers Chinese New Year Chinglish Christine Choi CIEE Coco Zhao Columbia University Comet McNaught Contemporary Chinese Art Courtesans Cui Jian D22 dancing Darfur dartmouth college David Spindler Democracy Digital Media City Documentary Film Dongtan drama Driving in China earthquake ECNU Campus Eco-City Ed Lanfranco Education ehwa university Environment Ethnicity Family food Frederic Wakeman French Concession French Concession Tour Genocide Global Warming Globalization Great Wall Greg Girard H-ASIA Helen Feng Hollywood Hostesses Hunan Hutongs Interview Iraq James Farrer jazz Jia Zhangke John Cusack Kaiser Kuo Korea Literature on China Live Music long bar Lu Xun Lynn Pan Mao Livehouse Mao Years Mao Zedong MCLC Media and Censorship moganshan lu mountain climbing Mu Shiying Multimedia Muse Music night nightlife NYU NYU Shanghai Old Beijing Old Shanghai Olympics Pamela Crossley Paramount Ballroom park Parks and Gardens Peace Hotel Peter Hessler Phebe 3D Piano plays poetry Policing Shanghai Politics Preservation Propaganda public manners Putuoshan Railways Red Collector rock concert Seoul Sex Sex in China shanghai Shanghai Bund Shanghai Fox-trot Shanghai Literary Festival Shanghai Photography Shanghai's Dancing World shaoxing sichuan Snapline Songdo sports Spring Steve Sweeting students Study Abroad Programs SUBS summer program Sustainability Suzhou Sydney tess johnston Thomas Dolby Tianzifang Tibet tour traffic Transportation travel TwoCities Gallery Ullens Center Uluru UNSW Victor Mair Video Wei Hui Whitey Smith William T. de Bary World Expo xintiandi Xu Jilin Yangzi River Yonsei University zhabei Zhabei Park Zhang Ailing Zhoushan Islands Ziyo




« Happy Children’s Day, Shanghai | Main | Nightlife in China: A Special Issue of _China An International Journal_ »
Wednesday
May212008

A Message to China: Stop Eating Shark Fin Soup! 鱼翅汤背后的成本:鲨鱼可能消失

For some years now, ocean scientists and many other concerned citizens around the world have been aware of the danger that shark finning is bringing to the world.  Sharks are being consumed by the millions, just for their fins.  After being brutally definned, their bodies are tossed back into the ocean to die.  This is going on in support of a multi-billion dollar industry surrounding the purported benefit of shark fins for human health—a completely unsubstantiated belief.  China is especially guilty of contributing to the extinction of sharks worldwide.  Here in China, shark fin soup is considered a delicacy, and people pay a premium to consume it. 

While many countries are waking up to this disaster, most people here in China are completely in the dark as to what the mass killing of sharks is doing to the ecology of the oceans. Many fancy restaurants in Shanghai and in other cities serve shark fin soup and some restaurants (such as Yu Xin on Weihai Road, where I ate last Sunday) have prominent displays of shark fin cartilege in glass cases.  Shark fin soup is especially popular for high-status events such as weddings or official banquets.  As far as I know, the Chinese government turns a blind eye to the damage that this industry is doing to the world's oceans.

Without these ancient predators, who mainly consume small fish (despite their image, sharks very rarely attack people and only 5 people die of shark attacks per year) roaming the oceans, the ecological balance is thrown off.  Statistics suggest that at least 100 million sharks are killed per year so that people in China (and elsewhere) can eat their shark fin soup.

This is a brutal trade that is destroying the shark population of the world.  You can help end it by refusing to eat shark fin soup and by telling restaurants in China not to serve it.  Let us hope that in time, China wakes up to the monumentality of this crisis, before all the world’s sharks have been killed.

If you want to learn more about the shark finning industry, I highly recommend the film Shark Water.  It’s a beautiful film and a gripping story of the struggle of a few brave people to help stop shark fishing in the Galapagos and Costa Rica—two of the oceans’ greatest preservation areas for sharks, including the hammerhead shark.

Here are some sources for learning more about this issue.

http://www.seashepherd.org/longline/longline_shark_finning.html


http://www.hsus.org/wildlife/issues_facing_wildlife/shark_finning/dying_for_a_bowl_of_soup.html

http://www.nytimes.com/2006/01/05/international/americas/05sharks.html

http://www.wildaidchina.org/Article/WildAidInTheNews/18.htm

Reader Comments (10)

While I totally agree that the trade is damaging and needs to be regulated, I also think it's unfair to point the finger at the Mainland. I have been offered just as much shark's fin in Hong Kong and Taiwan as I have during my time in China's mainland. As for the health benefits, I (once again) agree that they are hyped, but I have been told they are good for the joints...
May 23, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJennifer Thome
Thanks for taking the time to post your comment Jennifer. Much appreciated and you make a valid point. Of course Taiwan and Hong Kong are also places where the soup is consumed, as are other Asian countries. From what I've heard, people in Hong Kong and Taiwan are now more aware of the ecological ramifications of the trade, whereas Mainlanders are still in the dark. On the other hand, as my wife pointed out to me, very few mainlanders get the chance to eat shark fin soup, since it's so expensive. Yet in a country of 1.3 billion people (as opposed to several million in HK and Taiwan), the damage is still enormous. So I think it is right to target Mainland China since this country is more responsible than any other for the perpetuation of the trade in shark fins. As for health benefits, from what I understand about Chinese medicine (and western medicine) they are completely fictitious and have nothing whatsoever to do with Chinese medicine as it is really practiced by licensed practitioners. Nor do any other animal products such as deer or yak penis, bear gallblader, etc.
May 24, 2008 | Registered CommenterAndrew Field

heres the thing.

to chinese mainlanders, shark fin soup is as much a part of a wedding ceremony as cake is for americans/westerners.

of course the big difference is, cake is sustainable.
you can grow the stuff needed in your own back yard if you absolutely had to!

Shark fin soup ? Fishers cut the fins off of live sharks, then toss the still living shark into the ocean to slowly bleed to death - in that brutal and wasteful process, you gain 2 fins...enough to make soup for perhaps 25 people..so for a larger wedding you must kill 4-6 sharks.

And also, this is china we are talking about. the nation of 1.3 billion people.
that 1.3 billion number is very major when you consider how slow sharks breed, and how in demand thier fins are by that large ammount of people...its enormous pressure on sharks, when they take 5 years to reach sexual maturity. its no wonder they are dying out so quickly [10 years ago there was 10x as many sharks in the world].

If you add it up, its easy to see why the pracitce of eating shark fin is ridiculous on such a large scale..it is not sustainable at all. So in the short term if not stopped, it will leave the oceans sharkless and its ecology in chaos...all that for a bowl of soup - which btw - is tasteless [shark meat has no taste] - and its medicinal properties is based on superstition.
May 28, 2008 | Unregistered Commenterhue
It is ignorant for China to sell shark fin soup because it is killing the shark and making the population decline and if this keeps on going there will be no sharks in the future for others to study and enjoy if this goes on and it needs to stop China!
June 10, 2008 | Unregistered Commenteranthony may
It is ignorant for China to sell shark fin soup because it is killing the shark and making the population decline and if this keeps on going there will be no sharks in the future for others to study and enjoy if this goes on and it needs to stop China!
June 10, 2008 | Unregistered Commenteranthony may
Well at least the beaches are safer. Take that, Jaws.
July 24, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterJake
While I do oppose to the consumption of shark-fin soup, I also observe the double standard of many Westerners over this matter. Very few actions were taken to protect the cod population in the Atlantic Ocean and now there's an outcry over shark-finning.

Judging from comments like "China is ignorant", "1.3 billion number is very major when you consider how slow sharks breed, and how in demand thier fins are by that large ammount of people..." (Do you people truly believe every single person in China had shark-fins before? Do you folks have a clue how expensive these things are?) I must say the Sinophobic attitudes of many Westerners has to do with this international protest against shark-finning to a certain degree.
September 26, 2008 | Unregistered CommenterWarren
Thanks for posting your comment, Warren. I agree that Americans and others have overfished the Atlantic, and that overfishing in general is a global issue of great magnitude, but I don't agree that protest against shark finning is a result of "sinophobic attitudes." The problem is that shark's fin soup is a ridiculous luxury item, whereas cod is a food staple. Even if a tiny percentage of the Chinese population consumes shark fin soup, it does add up given the huge population. Population figures are something you just can't argue about. So if people in the PRC become more aware of the dangers of depopulating the world of sharks just so that they and others can enjoy a bowl of high-status boiled water, that's gotta be a good thing, eh?
October 3, 2008 | Registered CommenterAndrew Field
to hell with that entire babygirl killing culture and their ant colony dictatorship.
north america and europe should cut trade with china>china buys very few manufactured goods from the west- so the west looses jobs while china ruins the planet.
once they stop making money off of us, their communist party will go the way of libya's gaddafy
March 24, 2011 | Unregistered Commenterbarry
It is amazing how folks do not understand how insignificant they are.
This 'campaign' is much to do about nothing.

With the rise of China, we better eat all the shark fin soup we can now.
Assuming only top 1% of China can afford it, this is more than 10 million people.
In a few years, there may not be any sharks left unless you can raise them in farms.
Good luck trying to convince the upper class in China, Taiwan and Hong Kong to stop eating shark fin lol : )
That may cause WW3, whereas

I for one even brought a geiger counter to make sure the shark fin does not come from Japan, and even have a chelating diet for the mercury.
Though it is really strange why all the caring concern about PCB mercury etc, because these materials do not accumulate in the cartilage of sharks.

However, do beware not to eat too much blue fin tuna - the nice fatty tuna belly parts do accumulate the bad stuff.
June 3, 2011 | Unregistered CommenterWalter

PostPost a New Comment

Enter your information below to add a new comment.

My response is on my own website »
Author Email (optional):
Author URL (optional):
Post:
 
All HTML will be escaped. Hyperlinks will be created for URLs automatically.